4 February

Being God: Animals, Dogs, Cats And Fish Tanks

by Jon Katz
Being God

I know I am not God, I am reminded of my very limited powers every time I set foot in the Mansion and meet a beautiful person losing their mind, or meet a shell-shocked refugee child who tries to understand the taunts and threats he or she receives every day from other children here in the land of the free and the brave.

If I were God, the world would be quite different, of course, and yet I think animals often help me to get in touch with my idea of God, and to shape the world in my own image of him or her.

In his new book “God, A Human History,” the spiritual scholar Rezla Aslan writes that from the first, humans have wanted and needed a God in their lives, although there are too many versions of God to count.

“The very process through which the concept of God arose in human evolution compels us, ” he wrote, “consciously or not, to fashion God in our own image.” To do the same things to the idea of God that we do to dogs and other animals – we project our own thoughts, values and emotions onto them.

Because we love them and need them, they must be like us, or recognizable by us.I’ve seen a thousand paintings of Jesus dying on the cross but only a handful of him living in the world. We need him to suffer, I think, because we do.

When I think about my farm, I wrote once that the farmer is a God, in so many ways. He holds life and death in his hands every day. When a chicken is sick, I can condemn her to death and kill her on the spot.  The residents of the farm are absolutely dependent on Maria and me for everything they must have to survive – food, water, shelter, medical care.

We can sentence them to death anytime, for almost any reason. We can also save them. The farmer is the court of last resort. So, in a different way, is the pet owner, they depend on us for their very lives.

We have taken in scores of desperate animals on our farm – dogs, sheep, chickens, donkeys, cats. By admitting them into our world, we give them life, by denying them entrance we bring them death. These often seem to me to be the roles of God.

People often speak of the unconditional love our dogs and other pets give us, but it is quite conditional to me. Their very lives depend on us every day, and no dependent relationship is truly free or unconditional, women throughout history have testified to that.

I often wonder why an oddball child like myself, a loner and book geek, would have assembled so vast an empire of helpless fish in his childhood, and I think I am old enough to begin to see why. As much or more as anything in the animal world, fish tanks are our kingdom, we create them, and shape them and give them life, and care for them or neglect them or discard them at will.

Even the neediest person must struggle to emotionalize or anthropomorphize a fish, they are among the simplest and most mechanical of living things. Yet my mailbox is already full of people’s projections the complex emotions and needs and moods of Frida and Diego, and now Pleko:  look, we’ve done it already, we’ve give them names.

Am I not building another Cathedral?

Frida is adventurous, even artistic, was one message. Diego is a rascal, said another. Sometimes, Maria and I sit and watch: what are they like? What are they doing?

The process is underway. We get the animals we need.  Someone warned me right away that goldfish are a “gateway” to a world of money, hard work and suffering.

I already love sitting by the tank with my camera, trying to capture their emotions and moods and grace.

If you think of the historic functions of Gods, it is almost chilling to think of the similarities to what Gods are supposed to do, and what people with animals do. I choose the tank, clean it, landscape it and give it trees and plants. I decide who will live in the tank, how many, how old, what kind. Will they have light, or not?

The fish have no way of existing beyond what we choose to give them: fresh food every day.

When their tank is dirty, we clean it, when they need air, we provide it, when it is cloudy, we make it clear, when it too cold we make it warm, when there is conflict, we are the judge and the jury, we are life and death, justice and mercy.

I can give the fish everything I didn’t have, everything I wanted. We care for them as I wish I was cared for, I give them everything I did not have. I am paying attention I am constructing a perfect world however temporal.

I am God often on the farm. Maria as well.

When we euthanized old sweet Rocky. When I put Orson down for hurting people. When I shot a chicken who couldn’t walk. When we chose to keep Gus and treat  him rather than send him away or have him put to death. When I sent the old sheep off to be slaughtered. When I sent Elvis to be put out his misery and swollen legs.

And then,  think of the boy. Where did he get the energy and drive to assemble his vast universe, his own kingdom of living, dependent things. How powerful he was there, how much in command, how hidden and protected from a world he saw as cruel and hopeless. It begins to make sense as I look at Frida and Diego swimming back and forth.

I imaging this brought great comfort and joy to a little boy sitting alone in his room – his parents never once remarked on all of his gurgling fish tanks, never asked him where he got the money to buy these big and wired and bubbling and brightly lit little words, what was in them, why they were there. When they were gone they were never mentioned again.

This child, who felt so powerless and weak – he wet his bed every night, almost to college – and here, in his room, he could be the God of this peaceable kingdom, to which he sustained and gave life and presided over, unchallenged and omnipotent. And so well cared for.

When you have a fish tank, you become a kind of God, at least for a bit, at least in one way. You experience the awesome challenge and power of Godliness, of Godness. Small acts of great and resonating kindness.

Of course we humanize God and the divine,  how else are we to comprehend it? When we endow God with human attributes, writes Azlan, we divinize those attributes, so that everything good or bad about religion is merely a reflection of everything that is good or bad about us.

We create a super being endowed with human traits, but without human limitations. Sometimes, the world doesn’t have to be human at all.

I stood before my fish tank this morning with my camera, and set out to humanize Frida and Diego. What else could I do, what else could be expected of me to do?

Forgive me, I said to the fish as I sat watching them, exploring this primal, ancient and eternal form of spirituality.

I know i have life and death power of you, and I know Maria and I will be good to you. And I know you will never grasp or understand what I am telling you. But I need to say it, anyway.

But I am just me and you are just fish. It may  be that  you are God, come to lead and nurture me. No fish was ever born arrogant.

2 Comments

  1. Powerful post, Jon, That little lonely boy became a beauiful human being. Thank goodness you had those fish, allowing you some peace and comfort amidst the turmoil of your childhood.

  2. Your thoughts are appreciated. I was reminded of one of my husband’s favorite quotes by Voltaire, a French philosopher during the Enlightenment period, “In the beginning God created man, and man has been returning the favor ever since.” (That may not be quite word for word, but you get the idea.)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email SignupFree Email Signup