
November 15, 2007 – Cold, raw, rainy. Izzy and I have been hospice volunteers for nearly three months now, and a friend asked me why I haven’t written about the experience. Good question. I guess in part because I haven’t quite got a bead on how I feel about it. Most of my friends thought it was a poor idea to become a hospice volunteer, in that it would be draining, distracting, and depressing. It has, in fact, been a great gift to me, and I want to write about it.
The training was thorough, exhausting, and helpful. The fact that it was so serious and encompassing – talks, role-playing, films, workshops, lectures, substantial reading, talking, answering a lot of tough questions – was the first signal that I had joined an organization that was serious about what it did. So were the other volunteers, all warm, empathetic and eager to help people. The training, conducted by Keith Mann, coordinator of volunteers, prepared me well.
I remember a hospice worker talking about the “mistreatment of the dying,” a term that stuck with me. She meant that in our society, the dying are shunned, isolated in homes, nursing homes, hospitals, often removed from our sight and consciousness.
Often, they are uncomfortable, and in pain, and many people – I was certainly one of them – avoid death and the dying whenever possible. So the dying suffer all the more. We don’t know what to say to death, or what to do, and we don’t wish to be reminded that we will all fall, so we often stay away. I was a police reporter in several big cities, and I saw a lot of death – too much. But I was always at some distance, and never got to know the people whose deaths I covered.
Now, I do get to know them and the families struggling to care well for them. And it’s a pleasure, a gift to me.
Hospice is about helping the dying to be as comfortable and to end their days with as little pain as is possible. Also to give them and their families some relief in a society that doesn’t provide a lot of help. It isn’t a happy thing to die, but it doesn’t have to be an awful or depressing thing, either, as I’ve learned. It can be quite beautiful, something I wouldn’t want to avoid. And Izzy has been a big part of that.
Izzy has a great gift for a dog, which is intuition, and he can enter a strange home, go straight to the patient, and be appropriate. He never intrudes, jumps, pushes past the point where his attentions are welcome. He puts his head in somebody’s hand, jumps up on a bed or coach, and lies nearby. When they are in pain, or tired, he simply goes off to a corner and watches me.
The big surprise to me is that he knows what to do, and also that his presence brings so much joy and comfort to the people he is seeing. When we go into a home or nursing home, Izzy always pauses and looks at me, as if to get some cues. I don’t really have any. So he goes off on his own.
One woman, near death and unable to speak for months, smiled when Izzy lay down next to her, and began talking. A man with cancer asked to see Izzy just before he died. A man suffering dementia who hadn’t spoken in more than a year, began speaking after Izzy visited with him.
So much is written about the healing and mystical power of dogs and cats that is makes me wary. As those who have read my books know, I believe it’s important to respect the animal nature of dogs, not to turn them into self-serving notions of mystics, psychics, healers and spiritualists.
I wonder sometimes if Izzy’s gift comes from the fact that he was mostly alone for the first five years of his life, living in a fenced in area of a nearby farm. He seems to relish people, and watches me all the time. Jeff Meyers, a vet and friend, says that Izzy learns by watching me so closely, and there is something to that. But I also think that Izzy understands loneliness and need in some instinctive way, and is drawn to it. How else to explain how he enters a home, scans all of the people, and goes to the person who is dying?
I still feel that it’s a mistake to emotionalize and humanize dogs, but Izzy is a remarkable creature, and he is leading me to some extraordinary places.

I feel close to many of the people we have visited, and we have already lost some of them. The hospice workers remind us that unlike many other programs, there is usually only one outcome for the people we visit, and that is death. It isn’t going to get better, and there isn’t going to be a miraculous outcome, not usually. We don’t have good news to bring, aren’t there to cheer anybody up. So I have come to understatement what the social worker meant when she talked about the mistreatment of the dying. It is a powerful experience to go into home after home with Izzy and see people struggling to help their husbands, wives, children, end their days in dignity. They are often overwhelmed and lonely, frightened and suffused with love and pain. They are grateful for Izzy, as am I.
He is, in his own way, working to end the mistreatment of people who are ending their lives. I have never seen anyone need a dog as much, or get as much pleasure from one. Nor have I ever had a dog that could do what he does.
There are so many ways to look at death, and theologians and philsophers have never come to terms with it, it seems to me. My ideas are changing quite a bit as a result of my hospice work. In Plato’s time, one philosopher called death “the greatest of all evils,” but the moral philosopher Hannah Arendt said that on the contrary, death is a deity, a benefactor, precisely because it dissolves the union of soul and body, and thus seems to liberate the mind from bodily pleasure, just as consciousness prevents our bodily organs from functioning properly.
It is quite humbling, the power of these dramas, the struggle between life and death and love and dignity that goes in the houses, trailers and nursing homes we drive by all of the time. This week, Izzy and I sat with a loving wife who is watching her husband die, and she kept looking at her husband, and told us again and again, “what a gift my time with him is, what a gift.” Izzy came out from under a chair and came up to her, and put his head on her knee, and stared into her eyes, and she took his head in her hands and wept. “And what a gift you are, dog.”