28 May

What’s Behind A Mask?: The Politics Of Reconciliation

by Jon Katz

I stopped to see Amy McLenithan at her Country Cooking Wagon, I haven’t been by much during the coronavirus lockdown.

It was surprising to see her with a mask, and odd to be wearing one when I got my coffee.

They call it the new normal, and I’m getting used to it. Amy looked great and said her business was holding up. I missed her.

Before stopping at Amy’s, I made three stops along Main Street in my town – the hardware store, the post office and a convenience store.

It feels like the town is opening up, more men in trucks, more cars, more stores delicately moving to open. All along the way, I encountered groups of men who were not wearing masks or social distancing.

They were talking and gathering as they always do, not as health authorities and the governor are pleading with them to do.

Yesterday, I saw some stories about the growing the growing political divide over masks. The President isn’t wearing one and is encouraging his followers not to wear them, and this has upset medical authorities and many people who do wear masks and who believe it is callous and irresponsible for people not to wear them.

It makes me a little sick to see that masks are being used to divide us further and politicize this awful Pandemic. It speaks to the country’s broken soul.

It also challenges me to figure out ways to help undivide the people I live around. It’s time to make America kind again, and it has to start one person at a time.

The country is too big to handle for me, but listening has to start somewhere. If Nelson Mandela did it in  South Africa, we can do it here.

One of the men I met this morning told me that he doesn’t wear a mask in order to support President Trump. Everyone was jumping on him, he said.

I said I was sorry to see the masks divide us in our town. I said it was his choice to make, I don’t feel I can tell anyone to do. He was polite and offered to shake my hand.

I shook his hand. ( I admit I did use the sanitizer back in the car.)

This man then said he thinks people who wear masks are doing so in opposition to Trump, as a statement against him. I said I was wearing a mask to protect myself and others, and in good faith, but that we all had to answer to our own sense of what was right.

Another man waiting in line at the post office – he had no mask, looked uncomfortable when he saw mine, and moved away a bit  –  told me the virus might be serious in New York City, but not up here.

He seemed angry. The whole thing was a lot of BS, he said, from people who wanted to make the president looked bad and who didn’t give a shit about ordinary people.

I said I wasn’t in the business of telling other people what to do, and I understood the feeling of resenting the government’s intrusion into our personal lives. I said I often voted Democratic and I wore the mask because I believe the doctors who say I needed to, for my sake and others.

I said no politician, including Donald Trump, made my clothing choices. I said I did listen to Dr. Fauci and the CDC, but that was my choice, he had to make his own. You don’t need to explain yourself to me, I said, and I don’t need to explain myself to you.

He nodded and turned away and do his business.  He still seemed angry, but he nodded to me on the way out.

I don’t intend to march around talking to people about masks. But I’m figuring out what to do when it comes up.

I was wearing a mask for both conversations, and it was strange to think of this as a political statement. I did feel a bit like a wussy, the real men were not wearing masks. Then I rethought that..

My town has a lot of supporters of Donald Trump, it also has a bunch of transplanted New Yorkers who don’t care for the President and who are wearing masks.

So it is divided, although it rarely bubbles up.

A lot of the New Yorkers speak up and argue with the locals who aren’t wearing masks. Some even shout at them or move far away. Some argue. I can’t recall ever seeing an argument change someone’s opinion, online or off.

My feeling about it – some people won’t like it – is that I need to try and accept the feelings of other people. I don’t think I changed anybody’s mind, but I liked the fact that we did listen to one another.

I sometimes resent the mask also, there is little coronavirus up here, and I can understand why these men – most of them out of work now and hurting – are getting angry and vulnerable to different messages, and already feel divided.

I feel like I’ve got to start listening somewhere, and at some point, and I’m not inclined to rush to judgment on other people who have their own souls and consciences to consider.

I hate being told what to do, and I  hate doing that to other people. It’s too much like playing God to me.

I wear the mask on the admittedly remote chance that I will save my own life, I am an older man at risk, and as, and as importantly,  so that I might save the life of someone else.

I think wearing a mask is the right thing to do, for now, I have no reservations about it.

I can understand ignoring a politician, but I do listen to doctors, they have saved my life more than once, and have saved countless other people as well in recent months.

It is just too easy to judge other people when I am so flawed myself and have been judged so often by others.

So that’s where I am on masks. Generally speaking, and unless it relates to dogs, I don’t tell other people what to do.

I focus on what I do and make sure I like the face I see in the mirror each morning and do nothing to shame him. I also appreciate my town, these men, who are so different than me, have always rushed to help me when I needed help.

13 Comments

  1. Thank you for sharing your thoughts. To go within and to your own soul be true, that is probably the best advice for anyone trying to make sense of what has transpired and how the people in this country have reacted.
    It is heartbreaking to see an entire faction of the country, influenced by their political ideology, disavow the event of over 100,000 fellow countrymen expiring before their time in the span of the last 3 months,….simply because they don’t know them. I don’t even know how to wrap my mind around that.
    Thank you again for writing so well about how you are making your way through, it is a helpful reminder.

  2. I find it interesting that The United States of America has a higher death toll than any other country and it is far from over. It’s not about Trump or politics. I’ve lost two friends to this pandemic and I am so very, very disheartened.
    I agree that kindness is a necessary and needed antidote. I draw strength from the goodness of you and your readers.

  3. I pin this anger and confusion regarding masks on our president. From the time the CDC recommended wearing masks in public, the president should have set a good example by wearing one. It would have sent a message not just to his followers but to the entire nation to take this covid19 seriously and to follow those CDC guidelines. Instead he chose not to wear a mask, and now you have people thinking, if Trump doesn’t wear one, why must I? I live in Wisconsin where the state is gradually opening up. Some people wear masks while others don’t. Our library requires them. Most importantly, we shouldn’t be hassling each other one way or the other. Remember, we’re all in this together, right?

  4. Hi Jon,

    Wear the mask and take care of yourself…Here in Texas there is a lot of the same…especially since here in Dallas we locked down and have kept it under control. So people think all kinds of nonsense.

    I did want to ask if you could tell me the name of the disinfectant fogger that you helped purchase for the Mansion…I was going to recommend it to my principal for our school when it opens up next August, hopefully. Thank you so much,

    Carol

  5. You probably weren’t trying but your photographic skills have caught a naturally beautiful head of hair, no small feat. (Amy McLenithan)

  6. Ironically Jon, I wear a mask specifically because I am not in a high risk group. I am so nervous to be an asymptomatic carrier. I fear since I am 53 & no underlying conditions that I could be spreading the virus unknowingly. My best friend is a doctor & she has stressed the best way to take care of the vulnerable is to wear a mask. To me it is a symbol that I am willing to be uncomfortable to protect others. It makes me sad that medical advice is seen as a political agenda.

    When I hear people say they aren’t wearing a mask to support Trump, I just pray they won’t get sick. Trump says he is tested multiple times a day, if others had that same opportunity, maybe not wearing a mask would make sense. I don’t want to argue either, but feel this is not about politics but public health.

  7. I’m sorry, but I can’t even begin to understand the people who refuse to wear a mask. It’s a moral issue. You could possibly be causing someone illness or death by not wearing one. If someone wants to purposely harm me, or my child, or my aged mother, or any human being on this Earth, are you seriously asking me to get into their mind and try to understand where they are coming from, what their political or vain reasons are? This should not even be a debate. For the sake of human kindness and respect for each other please wear a mask.

  8. “You don’t need to explain yourself to me, I said, and I don’t need to explain myself to you.” Your statement is acceptance in a nutshell, Jon. I will remember this as my mantra, in addition to a few others – always be kind, the more I judge, the less I love, and lastly, what Anais Nin said, that we don’t see people as they are, we see them as we are.
    Thanks again for the inspiration.

  9. What we need to do is manufacture red masks that say “Trump” or MAGA and offer one to anyone who says he’s not wearing a mask because he supports Trump. I wonder if any of those men would accept one, though.

    1. Thanks Mimi, good to hear from you, and thanks for the note…I see very few local men wearing a mask..

  10. For the record, I AM a Trump supporter and ALWAYS wear my mask. I have never given a spot of thought about him as to whether I wear it or not. I wear it because it’s the safe thing to do. I think a few individuals are making this a political issue and are just stirring the pot. I just googled it and it would seem that the majority of people, BOTH Republicans and Democrats, are in favor of wearing the mask.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email SignupFree Email Signup