18 June

What Is An Artistic Aesthetic Anyway? Do I Have One? Creativity And Ruthlessness

by Jon Katz

What is an artistic aesthetic? Am I an artist? Do I have an artistic aesthetic? Is it something I should care about?

Today, Maria joined the ranks of several other people in saying my aesthetic regarding my flowers and my garden was original and different. She is both an artist and a long-time gardener.

She carries a lot of weight with me.

Other artists are also contacting me about my flower photos and garden bed and telling me I have a very original “aesthetic” from most gardeners about my pictures.

I suspect this is something essential and something I should care about, even if no one else does.

I am not an artist but a writer, but the flower photos and their generous response bring me closer to my seeing myself in that way.

So do the comments of the few artists and art lovers comparing my photo pictures with the paintings and work of the quite extraordinary Georgia O’Keeffe. That has my attention; I am a serious fan.

I never compare my work to hers, that would be self-destructive, but I can’t say it hurts my feelings when someone else does it.

The flower stuff has my head spinning for lots of reasons. It is transformative already, and I am trying to understand what it means.

Since I have heard the term aesthetic when it applies to famous artists but never really focused on it, it seemed like remote artistic jargon. I realized today, when Maria brought it up, that I didn’t even know what it meant, let alone what mine might be.

First, I asked myself, what does it mean in the dictionary and according to real artists like Maria?:

“What is artistic aesthetic? Aesthetics is the study of beauty. An artistic aesthetic is the collection of stylistic choices an artist uses to make a work beautiful or to communicate meaning, value, or emotion to the observer.

 

Maria said most gardens are carefully and thoughtfully planned and considered  – one kind of flower here, some space here, some tall ones here or there, colors separated carefully from one another.

Every flower has a place in every garden, and as Maria pointed out, every aesthetic is different.

Maria said the exciting thing about my aesthetic is that I don’t think much about which flower I choose or where they will go.

Mostly, I am thinking about how the flowers can be photographed and how they look in the context of color, light, and one another.

I dig holes and plant them randomly. Somehow, she says, “You have an absolutely gorgeous garden.” Yes, I do; I see that.

I am not a serious gardener by inclination or ability. I am in it for the pictures, and I see them as the pathway to being a true artist, creating stylistic choices that make a work beautiful to other people and emotionally stirring to them and to me.

My garden beds are as chaotic as my study and much of my life. It’s the way my mind works or doesn’t work. Clutter and chaos have shadowed me my whole life.

I guess my aesthetic would be a kind of gardening chaos, all sorts of flowers thrown today pretty much at random, without too much knowledge or reason or research possessing the color, shapes, and value that make for a good, hopefully significant, photograph one day.

My garden bed flowers come straight from the gut, almost independently of my consciousness. Everywhere I do is like that. Maria says she loves my chaos; it is one of the things she loves the most about me. She says she doesn’t want to be with a boring person, and I am not dull.

A picture has to touch me and touch my heart before I hit the shutter. I am emotionally engaged with every picture I take.

But I am also ruthless at times. I was a relentless reporter; I always got the story. I didn’t care what people thought of me.

If a sheep is sick, I will want to shoot it. If a dog has a terminal illness, I want to help them leave the world quickly and comfortably.

If I don’t wish to photograph one of my flowers, or the picture isn’t what I hoped for, I will get rid of it by giving it to Maria for her gardens or throwing it over the pasture fence for the donkeys to eat.

At the core, my flowers are about my photography, not about flowers.

They are coming to mean much more to me than that as I get to know them. But I still will cull my flowers until I get the ones that are special and fit my aesthetic, if that is the right word. I won’t have any malingerer in my garden beds.

My interests and those of flower lovers collide; we are bound to one another. I will never remember all of their names. Their support has made this possible for me.

I’ve worked hard to decide which flowers to choose, to experiment with many different ones. I’m learning a lot.

There is some reason for my madness. I think of centerpiece flowers surrounded by colorful and original plants that make up a whole I see, but only I can see.

I think of rows of tall flowers whose colors feed into one another and offer a stunning backdrop. I think of bright colors and flowers with character. Like me, flowers lead open lives.

They have no secrets. In my mind, I see colors merging, filling the frame with color.

I have worked hsrd on my floral photography; it’s taken me years to collect the cameras I need, a few lenses I know I need, and the skills to understand light, exposure, and the environment related to photography. I’ve read a dozen books about photography, none about flowers.

Yet the flowers are central; the photography is only as good and beautiful as they are.

I mostly leave the flowering to the elements. I trim them, water them, and watch them closely. They are changing me.

I am coming to think of my flowers more and more – they have indeed brought out something good in me  – but I think we all know I am a much better photographer than a gardener, and that is really what I want to be, that and a good writer.

I see that the flowers are my ticket to being a true artist.

 

My garden beds are chaos, different kinds of flowers thrown together for their color and individuality.

One bed is devoted to Nastirtiums, and one to poppies and flowers that are two feet tall or more. I love photographing all kinds of Begonias and anything with deep and rich colors. I love going inside the flower and seeing them as sentient beings with souls and spirits.

I want to catch their souls, get in close, capture their beauty and passion, their sensuality and sexuality, and stir the emotional response to them that so many people have. Flowers are essential right now; they give us all something beautiful and inspiring to comfort us from the cruelty and anger boiling outside of ourselves.

I’ll have to think about this aesthetic business; I know I have one that differs from most people who garden more seriously and thoughtfully than I do.

My idea is to take the most beautiful pictures that stir good and strong emotions in people and help point me toward the kind of person – and artist – I want to be. I want people to love my pictures of flowers as I love them and to gain as much comfort and good vibrations from them as I am getting.

Some people tell me they cry seeing them. That is what I want, for the people who see my flowers to feel them, not just look at them.

At the core, as I’ve written before, I’m a Beavis &Butthead guy. I dropped out of two colleges before they could throw me out, and I am almost entirely self-educated and self-motivated, for better or worse.

I have never gotten along too well with teachers, most of whom mistook my Dyslexia for stupidity. I knew early on that life would have to teach me, not teachers or my parents.

Like Beavis and Butthead, I am free because I am stupid.

Since I have never learned what I am supposed to do, I do what I want to do, and I defend that freedom fiercely, sometimes, as we know, too fiercely.

Even those who like what I do would like me sometimes to shut up and do my work. It’s good advice.

I am getting there and am happy, even proud,  to be getting there.

I like the idea of capturing photographic images that stir people’s emotions. I’d like that as an aesthetic choice. I believe I can do that.

I also believe that the flowers I photograph will only be as good or as creative as my work to develop a deep and authentic spiritual life from day to day evolves.

This, after all, is what an aesthetic is all about for me.

Humility is the spiritual hinge on which the rest of my creative life depends. The more truth I learn about myself, the more emotion I can bring to my photographs, and the more people they will touch.

I want to be an artist and feel entitled to the title; I’ve wanted that for much of my life.

But first, I have to be sure I am one, so my floral aesthetic is about learning the truth about myself and sharing it in the open.

Then, I’ll not only have a fully developed aesthetic, but I will also understand what that means.

 

 

17 January

Ruthlessness. Grabbing Hold Of Myself…

by Jon Katz
Ruthlessness
Ruthlessness

My first job in mainstream journalism was as an editorial assistant – they called it a copy boy then – at the New York Times.  Harrison Salisbury, a mythic journalist whose copy I carried back and forth, sat me down one day and told I had to be ruthless to be a journalist.

Some years later, my first editor – she worked at Bantam Books – sat me down for coffee and told me I had to be ruthless to be a book writer.

I took them both at their word and was often ruthless. As a reporter, I often sat by the bodies of dying people on remote roads after accidents recording their last words before the police arrived. I stole photographs of dead sons and daughters from fireplace mantels so we would have a picture for the paper. I called parents on the phone very night and asked them if they had anything to see about their sons who had been killed in Vietnam.

I went where I was not wanted and not welcome, I could always find the window to crawl through, in people, in buildings.

As a book writer, I ran through agents, wrote a book a year for 27 years, toured the country at readings, did thousands of interviews, nothing but my daughter ever came ahead of my writing. I endured countless rejections, criticism, financial challenge.

I am still a writer, and it is still true that I have to be ruthless at times to do what I do, I suppose it is an integral part of creative life, and of me now.  I meet a lot of ruthless people along the route, harder people than me.

Today, I read a wonderful new novel from Elizabeth Strout (Olive Kitteridge) called My Name Is Lucy Barton.

There was an especially beautiful passage beginning on Page 177 where the protagonist, Lucy Barton, is told by a neighbor in New York City that she had to be ruthless if she was to become a writer.

And I think how I did not go to visit my brother and sister and my parents because I was always working on a story and there was never enough time. (But I didn’t want to go either.) There never was enough time, and then later I knew if I stayed in my marriage I would not write another book, not the kind I wanted to, and there is that as well. But really, the ruthlessness, I think, comes in grabbing onto myself, in saying: This is me, and I will not go where I can’t bear to go – to Amgash, Illinois – and I will not stay in a marriage when I don’t want to, and I will grab myself and hurl onward through life, blind as a bat, but on I go!

  This is the ruthlessness, I think.

  My mother told me in the hospital that day that I was  not like my brother and sister: “Look at your life right now. You just went ahead and….did it.” Perhaps she meant that I was already ruthless.”

__

A fine novel touches us in that way, we can see ourselves in it.

Maria had read the same book just before I did, the minute I heard of it I bought it for her, and knew it was for me as well. We just looked at one another and understood without words how life sometimes requires us to be ruthless in order to grab hold of ourselves and and hurl onward through life.

29 December

Zip And The Wild Kingdom. The Other Name For A Barn Cat? A Wild Animal

by Jon Katz

It was raining hard this morning when I stepped out for my daily photo-taking and Zip meeting.

He wasn’t waiting for me, so I walked around the yard looking for him. I spotted him a long way off; he was just a black dot on the marsh, but I zoomed in on him, surprised he was walking around in the cold rain.

The iPhone  15 Pro Max has a superb zoom so I could see him from a distance.

Zip showed me that he was a wild animal like so many cats. He is ruthless, relentless, and murderous; he sometimes walks like a panther. I was mesmerized watching him hunt in the marsh full of prey – birds, moles, mice, frogs, snakes. I’m glad he likes me.

People keep telling me I’m a “cat person” now, but I’m unsure what that means. I love Zip, but I doubt he will ever have the impact on my life that Rose, Frieda, Izzy, Red, and Zinnia have had.

At each step of the way, dogs have marked and shaped the passages of my life. We’ll see about Zip.

I owe my dogs more than I could ever repay. They kept me company when I was alone, cheered me down, walked in the woods, and were silent when I worked; they made me smile, protected me, and inspired me.

The therapy work I did with my dogs altered my life and helped show me how to get older gracefully.

This is why I don’t care for labels much – red and blue, progressive or radical,  extremist or conservative, dog or cat – they pin people in. Instead of getting to know each other, we label them and tag them for life rather than talking to them or getting to know what they are about.

It is, I think, more important to know the people who are different than those who are the same as me. The Internet has made that difficult, as many people look at screens for hours daily.

I love many animals – donkeys, dogs, chickens, and a barn cat. Life is quite diverse. I think I’m a Zip person; that works for me. I love a lot of different animals and hope I stay that way. I have to admit that Zip is something new to me. We’ve had barn cats all along, but none were like Zip.

He is the most affectionate and wild creature I’ve ever encountered.

I saw his technique. He approaches the marsh’s edge, walks on a foot, and then jumps back to listen for movement. When he hears something, he jumps in. Sometimes, he wades into the wet marsh and sits still, waiting for some chipmunk or mouse. God helps the creatures he catches; he plays with them, lets them go, chases them, and eventually eats them.

He’s the only animal I’ve gotten close to that relishes killing and torturing things and then climbs into my lab for some cuddling and a nap. Wow.

I felt like I was on the African prairie watching a tiger or a lion.

It is a joy to watch Zip evolve and get comfortable. He is growing in savvy and patience; I suspect he caught and ate something on the spot. I was getting soaked, so I turned back towards the house. When I looked up on the porch, Zip had returned; I can’t imagine how he moved that quickly. Maybe Zip is a ghost who can walk through walls and fences.

He is the perfect barn cat.

We had our meeting, scratching and stroking. This thing about animals is fascinating to me, in my life, purring one minute, stalking the march murderously and silently the next. I could watch him for a long time and never get bored.

15 December

Getting Acquainted/ Morning Meeting. Zip Showed Us His Grisly Side Today

by Jon Katz

Zip is still getting acquainted with the other animals on the farm. He is also faithful to our daily meetings, one around 9 a.m. and one in the afternoon between 3 and 4 p.m.

He spends the morning saying hello to everybody and the afternoons hunting and killing. Cats are not simple animals. He shows no fear or concern for any of the animals, even though they are much bigger than him.

Maria took this photo of me and Zip this morning as I came out in my bathrobe to take pictures, and he was waiting for me. We always have something to say to one another.

 

The first photo above was taken as he rounds through the pasture. He’s touched noses with just about every animal in the place.

We discovered he was bringing his kills into the barn and putting them in a box to eat later. I thought I saw him carrying something significant into the barn. I was right.

It is a pretty horrible box; he is a ruthless and skilled Barn Cat. The squirrel was giant, more than a foot long. I couldn’t tell what the bloody remnants were from.

Maria says the laws of the Barn Cats apply. If he kills it, he will get to eat it.

Cats are barbarians, I remember, mixed with some affection and sweetness.

Zip is very much a hunter. I’m happy he’s not hunting me. I love his Jekyll and Hyde persona – cuddly one minute, murderous the next.

14 November

Peaceable Kingdom, Always A Beautiful Sight

by Jon Katz

One reader kindly suggested that some of my photos remind her of Andrew Wyeth. I blushed when I read that; how kind, but I’m afraid I’m not close to Wyeth in my pictures, although it was sweet music to my ears. I feel a lot of emotion in my feelings these days.

The sight of the donkeys and sheep all sitting down peacefully and feeling the sun that appeared this afternoon was endearing to me, and I felt how beautiful the idea of the Peaceable Kingdom is and how sad we humans can’t seem to find it outside of our imaginations.

It was a beautiful sight for me.

We have learned here that the natural world can be ruthless; I sometimes think everything I see in nature is prey to everything else. We see a lot of skeletons around here. But animals only eat when hungry; humans eat for greed, power, and mangled spirits.

I love looking at the animals and thinking about how peaceful they are and what lessons there are for us.

Bedlam Farm