12 April

Gifts Of The Virus:Learning To Love My Sister Again

by Jon Katz

I’ve been telling stories all my life – newspapers, books, blog, photos – but I couldn’t begin to tell the story of my sister and me. I just couldn’t bear it.

We grew up together in a hellish place, and we were very close, we leaned on one another, talked to one another, held one another through some truly dreadful years.

We both suffered from some severe emotional and psychological issues, from incest to abuse to severe collapses.

I don’t need to say any more about that here, it gives me the chills just to think about it, and it doesn’t matter anymore.

Jane and I have always loved one another, but we have not always known how to talk to each other or accept one another, and we lost contact for very long periods of time. I never stopped worrying about her, but it took me a long while to get over the fact that I could never really help her, and then I  had trouble understanding her as a person who didn’t want help from me, she wanted her little brother back.

I always wanted to save her, but I forgot to know her, or let her know me. Neither of us could ever get comfortable, too much heavy water under the bridge.

We always managed to stay in touch, but it was often tense and painful for both of us. She moved to upstate New York soon after I did, and also had a farm with animals; she bought a house hundreds of miles away.

I’ve been to see her once or twice; she had never come to see me except when I married Maria, she showed up for the ceremony and then left quickly.

Apart from everything else, she hates to leave her dogs alone for long. It is quite ironic that we both ran to the country that dogs are an essential part of both of our lives.

Like me, Jane has worked all of her life to heal her wounds and move forward and do some good. She had some dark times, and while we always cared for one another, we couldn’t quite find a way to talk comfortably.

When I broke down eight or nine years ago and was alone, she appeared out of the mist and walked me through my darkness, she talked to me on the phone every night or as often as I needed for months and months when I was desperate. She knew exactly what was happening to me; it had happened to her.

Nobody else could see it.

I do not believe I would have survived without her, and then when Maria came into my life, she receded again, and our connection was sporadic.

We know each other as no one else will ever understand either of us, we each were present and saw what happened to the other, that is a bond that could never be broken, and our love for each other has never faltered. But it was never ordinary either.

Now, at 74, she decided to take a job in a supermarket chain as a cashier because she wants to be helpful and useful during this crisis. She always wants to do some good; I think it is healing for her, as it is for me.

She is at risk, of course, more than 40 grocery chain workers have died of the coronavirus, but it is patronizing for me to worry about her, she is my big sister, and she has been through a lot worse. She can take care of herself.

I’m not sure which one of us has changed more in recent years, but somehow the coronavirus has brought us back to the place of love and connection where we both started.

She lives alone, in a house with her six dogs, in a place that makes our farm seem like Manhattan. She likes it that way; she has some friends she holds dear and doesn’t want or need more.

We each are the last connection we have to any members of our family, and it is important to me that we keep it. And we alone know our stories and can testify to them. We often ask each other if what happened could have happened.

Sometimes we don’t believe it ourselves, we are witness to one another, we are each other’s reality. My sister is brave and smart, she deserved so much better than she got. But she is happy in her life, doing what she wants, living as she wants, still doing the work she needs and wants to do to be whole.

She is never content to rest or sit on any laurels

Suddenly, the walls have come down, and we laugh and remember and yak like the loving brother and sister that we once were to each other. When she freaks out over the craziness of a supermarket in the Spring of 2020, she calls me, and I call her back.

There is no tension, no awkwardness, no resentment or discomfort. I can help her when she asks, but that is not what our relationship is about.

Somehow, the virus has brought us back in time, where we sat up talking and listening while my parents tore each other apart downstairs. She is sensitive, like Maria, all the anger and tension went right through her.

We could, of course, hear everything. We ran away together a dozen times when we were small, but we never got farther than my grandmother’s house, five or six miles away.

I fought hard for much of those early years to get help for Jane, but it turned out she was able to help herself, it just was a long and hard road. It took me a while to come to see her true self.

I accept her strength and judgment, I am not her mother or father, and she has come to accept me also as the person I am and have worked hard to be.

So we just talk. It feels wonderful to be able to do that. We are so different yet so much alike.

Slowly, day by day, my love for my sister is seeping back, not all at once, but one talk at a time. I think we are both a little wary, but getting past it.

I look forward to talking to her. We laugh and joke with one another. Yesterday, she texted me and said she needed a favor. We are coming to trust each other again, in the way a brother and sister should.

I texted right back and said I knew what it was; she wanted Maria to make her a special mask for her to wear at the supermarket. She said that was right, she wanted a beautiful one,  striking enough that people would ask where she got it, and she could answer “my sister-in-law made this for me, she is an artist!”

I wanted to cry, but I laughed.

“You won’t believe this,” I said, but I just asked Maria if she would make a beautiful mask for me, one that would get people to ask about it so I could say ‘my wife is an artist.’ She made this mask for me.”

Maria said she would be happy to make masks for both of us on Monday.

12 Comments

  1. The proper words to describe you stories escape me. I don’t want the words to sound trite. This one touched my heart. A true story of siblings. Beautiful.

  2. This was such a poignant story and really made me think about my brother, who was 16 months older. As young children, he was my defender, but also my tormenter, as was his way of showing love I suppose. There was violence beyond what anyone would consider acceptable today, and every time I witnessed beatings by my father, I cried for my brother. He always tried to ignore it and act tough, but I could see through his pain. Years later, when both of us were married with families, I tried to approach the subject of our childhood, but he would brush it off like it never happened and change the subject. I stopped asking. At the age of 34, he killed himself, and I wonder all the time if I had kept asking him to talk about it, would it have changed things? Would he have gotten professional help? I’ll never know. At 74, the pain of it has never gone away. I wish there had been a way to help him and wonder what kind of relationship we would have had in our old age.

    1. Thanks Sissy, I know how you feel, I always felt I had to help my sister and never could Now I can help her the most by not feeling responsible for her any longer..it was an awful burden…

  3. Siblings are a mysterious bond. I’m always amused at how different my sister and I are from one another. But there is a fine thread of similarity sewn into each of us.

  4. Jon, this was a beautiful piece. It’s a wonderful thing about being an adult, and being able to see our siblings in the present, rather than in the past. (This understanding took years of work and counseling for me, too.) I am glad that you and your sister can have a relationship now, that works for both of you.

  5. I hope for a time like this with my brother. There are some similarities in our life, and I know things have been worse for my brother and continue to be this way. I feel so much compassion for him but I fall into the helper mode and he resents me for this. It’s very hard to accept the way things are.
    It is wonderful that you are at a point where there is some joy in your relationship.

  6. I am so glad that you have connected again. I used to tell my older brother that he was the first boy I loved and I never stopped. He was a great big brother as well as my friend. Nobody knows you like a sibling. I never laughed as hard with anyone as I did with him. I lost him nearly five years ago and miss him every day.
    I hope your words will help others reconnect. It’s another way that your kind heart is reaching out.
    Thank you, Jon

  7. Abuse is never easy to overcome. I too was victimized, spent years in counseling, God works in mysterious ways. Now I work in a women’s shelter for domestic violence. Helping people and animals who have been abused is my way of paying the world back for what the world gave to me all those years ago
    God bless you and your work.

  8. This was exactly the right piece for me to read today. My 2 sisters and I are living hundreds of miles apart. All 3 of us are over 70, each of us lives alone (I have my dog and my younger sister has a horse, but my older sister is truly alone). They are 2 of the most important people in my life and I love them both. That’s always true, but now more than ever. My older sister and I have always struggled with our relationship, but have been working on it over the past decades and have made a lot of progress. Yesterday, she came apart some in reaction to the stressful time we are living in and accused me and my other sister of some things that were simply a matter of miscommunication and misinterpretation. I’ve managed not to take it personally and have been working on keeping our relationship intact. Your lovely piece is a good reminder to me of how important it is to keep working on it. Thank you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email SignupFree Email Signup