1 December

Chronicles Of A Dog Steward: Ditching The Hood

by Jon Katz

I have never been one of those dog people who believe they can go online for 15 minutes and know more than their vet, who has gone to school for six years and is heavily in debt as a result.

Vets have helped my dogs, saved them, and put them down with great care and mercy. I trust them and defer to them.

Except for one thing – the awful plastic hoods and cones many vets put on dogs after surgical procedures. For years, I’ve objected to them, fought about them, and finally, thanks to inflatable collars, refused to keep them on my dogs.

Until Sunday, when I wrote about Zinnia’s surgery, I didn’t know about the inflatable collars. Several of the blog readers did know and suggested it to me. I went right over to Chewy.com.

As a veteran of many years of therapy, I accept that it could be my problem as much or more as it is a problem for dogs. My vet would never hard a dog or any animal, she doesn’t see the hood the way I do.

Dogs are adaptable and accepting as a general rule, but my dogs – border collies and Labs – have never been accepting of these long hoods and cones, which obscure their vision, block their ability to smell the ground, affect their hearing and sight, and in my experience,  frighten and confuse them.

My very competent vets and vet techs disagree with me and smile knowingly when I bring this up, just another dog lover who has odd ideas about animal health care.

But I feel the hoods are wrong.

I consider myself the steward of my dogs; I speak for them; I am their advocate. I am not their boss or partner or daddy; I’m a steward; it is my responsibility to care for them and represent them.

Yesterday, Zinnia was spayed, and the surgery went well. This morning, I went to pick her up, and she came out with a hood/cone on. We gingerly lifted her into the car and brought her home.

I was supposed to walk her only on a leash for two weeks.

Zinnia has only been on a leash once or twice in her life, and I was confident I could handle it without one. She follows the “heel” command and also “get busy.”

I opened the car door, made sure she jumped out slowly, and then watched as she tried to navigate this hood, which stuck out well ahead of her nose. She circled and circled – she always sniffs the ground before peeing, and she couldn’t find it with the hood. She got anxious and confused and kept looking to me for directions.

I called her to me and took the hood off.

She went and sniffed the ground and peed. And she really had to go.  I got angry. I heard that old voice going off in my head: this is not going to stand.

This seemed cruel to me, not lasting or vicious abuse, but thoughtless disregard for both the dignity and security of the dog.

I have tremendous respect for vets, they know more about dogs than I will ever know, but I felt a strong sense of responsibility to do right by my dog – seeing her confused and spinning around and unable to figure out how to eliminate triggered my steward button.

Dogs are not people or children, and I don’t treat them that way. I ask a lot of my dogs – trust, obedience, training, respect, and affection – and they are owed the same. I am not an easy dog owner, but I am a fierce steward.

We have a contract; I keep my part; they keep theirs.

Today, the steward button clicked on.

I had ordered an inflatable collar that keeps dogs from licking their wounds and stitches. But the one I ordered isn’t coming until tomorrow.

I told myself to do the mature thing. I’d already bought the new collar, it was on the way. We didn’t need two and why not do the mature thing and just wait. One night in the crate with the plastic cone would not kill her.

So I get into the car and headed for Benson’s Pet Shop.

I knew I couldn’t wait until tomorrow. Tonight, Zinnia will be sleeping in her crate, and with that blue, soft, inflatable collar,  her movement, sight, smell, and peace of mind will not be disrupted and impaired.

And I’ll sleep better.

These cones drove my border collies crazy. Rose went wild, and I had to take them off, and Fate gets them off before we get a block from the vets. They can’t abide by them blocking their vision and movement.

I squawk about it every time, but on this, I get blown off.

If they choose, vets can have some of these inflatable collars in stock and put the bill’s cost.

There was no way she was sleeping with that hood on in a crate, not even for one night, let alone two weeks. I drove to Saratoga Springs in a kind of trance, a steward with a mission. Several people told me I was silly, and of course, they were right. At the store,  a young salesperson opened the door for me.

I told the salesperson what I needed, and she took me right over to a large-sized blue inflatable collar. “I know what you mean,” she said, “I can’t bear to put one of those plastic cones on my dogs.”

Because I speak for them doesn’t mean that I know what they are thinking. Zinnia an easy-going creature; she would have survived the done and gotten through it without scars or damage. But I think we can do better than that.

I have an honest relationship with my vet, and we’ll talk about it. Perhaps I’ll donate some inflatable collars so she can offer them as an option to people who might prefer them.  I got home from the pet store and blew the blue-collar up, and put it on Zinnia. She came out with me into the yard and did her business, all of it. She is lying at my feet as I write this, and I am unsure whether I am acting as a dog nut or as a responsible steward.

I took the collar off; for now, she really isn’t bothering her stitches, and I’m watching her. I’ll put it on at night when she goes into her crate downstairs.

Zinnia is the sweetest creature; she gives me nothing but love, obedience, and goodwill.  It’s not really about how she feels; it’s about how I feel about caring for my responsibility to her.

It’s my job to be her voice.

I can’t get by this feeling that the cone is wrong, the veterinary world can move past those cones with little trouble or cost.

Zinnia and I rarely speak, but we do trust one another – I can take a piece of meat right out of her mouth – and she is only moderately spoiled – that I owed her this, that is was my job to make sure she didn’t have to suffer the discomfort of surgery and the disruption of her senses and sense of the world.

Next time, I won’t argue with the vet, they don’t deserve that, but I’ll make sure to keep the new blue-collar hand. I’ll give my vet the one that’s coming tomorrow.

14 Comments

  1. I’ve shepherded a few dozen of the 70+ puppies I’ve fostered through the days following a spay or neuter, and I’m with you on the cone. They come out with a cone and the cone comes off as soon as we get into the car. A few have worn the soft donuts that I’ve had, but just for short periods of time. I’ve never had a dog that bothered the stitches, and I’ve watched them carefully for days. (I also mentally roll my eyes when told that a puppy has to remain still for 10 to 14 days after a spay/neuter. It’s tough enough to get them to be quiet for 10 minutes!) This isn’t to say that a dog will NEVER cause a problem if given access to the stitches, but I’ve never had any incidents. (Knock on wood.)

  2. If anyone is ever in need of a recovery collar, but unable to get an inflatable one I found that a travel neck pillow….the kind you take on a plane…works too. You just have to make a way to close the ends. I used a large baby diaper pin.

  3. Jon…
    Glad the inflatable collar is working out for Zinnia. Wish I knew about these earlier. Although some folks have reported problems (ineffectiveness or destruction), to me it’s worth a try.

    After surgeries, our fair-sized dogs had a rough time with the large plastic E-collars, especially passing through doorways or trying to lay their head down.

  4. You are right. It would be wrong to be otherwise. Our companion animals NEED us to be their stewards and take actions of behalf of them (even arguing, respecfully, with the vet when necessary). Thank you for being that person for Zinnia.

  5. I could not agree with you more on this issue. I’m curious what the vet says if you do raise the inflatable kind with them. Also, does it seem like it could pop, puncture or deflate if Zinnia runs into anything sharp? Not sure what is sharp that she would be near, but Murphy is Murphy is my life so curious your thoughts?!

  6. I’ve never used a cone on my dogs for the reasons you mention. Another option I’ve read about is use a pool noodle. Cut the noodle into pieces about two inches in length. Make a collar/necklace. Looks like it would work.

  7. I was offered the option of a tee shirt with snaps on the bottom when I had my Border Collie neutered. The catch was the tee shirt was an extra thirty dollars. Knowing my Border Collie and previous nightmares with plastic collars on my other dogs, I caved and paid the extra thirty dollars in addition to the cost of the neutering, Aside from him looking weird, it was easier. But my beef is why not include a tee shirt or inflatable collar as complimentary? What great PR. My son actually had to purchase the plastic collar for his dog and said the inflatable he ended up using was only two dollars more. I, too, have the utmost respect for vets, but I also walk out with sticker shock each and every time I have to take my dogs for this or that. If pillow collars and tee shirts were complimentary, people would be ecstatic. This, in my opinion, would be smart marketing for any veterinarian establishnent.

  8. Best invention ever! Our dachshund wore the “blue pillow donut” for two and a half weeks and other than mild itching now and then loved it. She used it as a pillow. Never again with the “cone of shame!” Best wishes for a speedy and no eventful recovery.

  9. My Bernese Mountain Dog has had two surgeries and cones and hoods were a disaster for her too. For wounds in her lower abdomen I found a “thunder shirt,” which normally comforts dogs in loud storms (mine loves storms) the Velcro attachments and the soft shirt were perfect, not intrusive and enabled my large dog to be comfy without that horrid hood.;)

  10. I totally agree with you–I respect our vet’s training and expertise, AND I have a blue inflatable donut for Shelby, which replaces the hard plastic cone as soon as we get home.

  11. I love the inflatable collars. My labs have done so much better with them than with cones. I volunteer at a free and reduced cost spay and neuter clinic a couple of times a month and tell everyone not to get a cone but to get an inflatable collar. Their dogs will be happier and so will they. I wish we could publicize them more!

  12. After seeing the confusion and anxiety on my 18 month boy I also strongly feel that the cones are just cruel. I also take my responsibility to care for him seriously and don’t think you have overreacted at all. My boy was recovering from a torn dew claw and after one attempt to have him wear the cone, I chose to fashion a sock into a type of guard that I could slip over his foot/lower leg at night( its true what they say about duct tape). Thanks for the info about the inflatable pillow and for a fellow follower’s suggestion to use a human travel pillow as a substitute if necessary. That will definitely be the solution(s) I choose if there’s a need in future.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email SignupFree Email Signup