The Brown/Red Hen (we never named her, we’d lost too many chickens) was with us almost from the very beginning of life on the second Bedlam Farm about nine years ago.
She had a long and good life for a chicken. She was industrious and ate many worms and bugs, and gave us many good breakfasts.
Maria is closer to the chickens than I am and made sure the Red Hen, as she called her (I called her the Brown Hen), had snacks and treats at least once a day. Maria cleaned out the roost faithfully and supplied it with fresh and heated water throughout the winter.
Of all the hens, the Red Hen was the most skittish, but in the past few months, she seemed to warm up to us. She always turned up for Maria’s 3 p.m. tea and gourmet snack party for the chickens.
(Fate has known this hen just about all of her life, and she came to say goodbye and sniff the body.)
I don’t cry over chickens, but it’s no fun for me to shoot one.
It is hard to lose an animal you’ve seen every day for years and who is an integral part of life and landscape here.
We were used to seeing her, and she was used to seeing us, although she never relaxed around any of the dogs. She was perhaps prescient.
It’s one thing to have a hawk or weasel come in and kill a chicken, another for one of our dogs to do it. It’s not Bud’s fault, but it stung.
Zinnia tried once or twice to become pals, as she is with the other chickens and the barn cats, but the Brown Hen wasn’t buying it.
She never trusted the dogs and was attacked last week by Bud after we left one of the gates open, and she never really recovered from the injury to her backside.
We did all the things one is supposed to do for an injured chicken (we don’t take chickens to the vets, but we talk to them about their injuries), but she continued to decline over the last two days.
She hadn’t eaten or been out of the roost for two days and wasn’t drinking any water. She was bent over and disoriented. We are planning on going away for a four-day vacation on Sunday, and we also didn’t want to leave a dying chicken for somebody else to have to deal with.
That means she was suffering from starvation as well as the injury; it was a red line for Maria and me. I felt strongly that we needed to help her leave the world in relative comfort, and this morning, Maria agreed.
I loaded the .22 rifle and went out to the back lawn.
Maria had carried her out of the roost.
She walked around a bit to get near her pal the White hen but then surrendered.
She just lay down next to one of the lawn chairs. I was able to get right next to her and point the rifle right next to her heart.
It’s odd, but I have the feeling that sick animals are ready to go when they are suffering; like the sick sheep I put down, she sat still and presented her heart to me.
I killed her with one shot, and she died in seconds, unusual for a chicken and a sign she was weak. I fired a second time to make sure, but she was already dead.
I used to apologize for shooting one of my animals; people with pets are often horrified by it.
But I consider this my most important duty as an animal steward – to prevent the suffering that so many humans inflict on dogs and other animals (and people) because they can’t let go. I love to post cute and endearing photos of my animals, but that is only part of the story, as anyone with a farm knows.
People love the bright side but not the other side.
Farms with animals see as much death as life. And Bud was doing what every animal on the earth does – killing living things for food and work. But it’s a sad thing when it happens.
I’ve learned to keep the process of dealing with a sick or dying animal simple and primarily private.
We don’t share the process; we just share the results and final decisions. That keeps well-meaning people from flooding us with advice – much of it, we have learned over the years – wrong or bad. Someone was berating me yesterday for not giving the Brown Hen painkillers. I told her we didn’t discuss animal health care with strangers on Facebook. And we don’t.
I no longer respond or post messages from some of the pet people and the extreme wing of the animal rights movement who believe no animal should ever die for any reason and that people with farms are, by their nature, cruel.
I have very little testosterone, I’m sure, and I’m not into shooting things. Before I came to live on the farm, the idea was beyond my imagination.
I wouldn’t dream of living here without a rifle, not for protection but for the animals.
Over the years, some people have come to equate keeping dogs and other animals alive at all costs by any means as a measure of their love. I see it as sanctioned animal cruelty.
People often brag about how much money they have borrowed and spent to keep their sick cats and dogs alive. Maria and I are in accord; we won’t do that.
We are called to do what’s best for them, not us. We are their advocates, their only voices.
On a farm, letting go is a life and death thing, a matter of mercy and the farm’s survival and health. The other hens would start pecking at her any minute now, and I am grateful I could do this; I wish we could do it for people when the time came.
Any vet when asked will say the worst part of their job is watching animals suffer because their humans don’t want to lose them.
The most moving part of this was the original White hen, who came at the same time the Brown hen came. This two have been inseparable all these years.
She slept next to her friend every night after the attack and stayed with her throughout the day, protecting her, it seemed, from the younger chickens, who turn cannibalistic when another chicken gets sick.
That’s the other side of the cute animal photos.
I publish the photo above not out of an interest in shocking but out of respect for this hen who lived peacefully and productively with us for all these years, gave us fresh eggs every day, and helped keep the yard free of ticks. She deserved to be acknowledged.
The life of the chicken is not romantic, they don’t write many books or make many movies about chickens. Almost every four-legged creature or hawk will eat them.
But they are peaceful and hard-working souls, part of the fabric and rhythms and traditions of any farm.
All they want in life are bugs and worms and occasional leftovers from humans.
After the Brown Hen died, Maria picked her up, and the two of us walked down into the woods. Maria left her in the open as an offering to the hungry animals who live out there.
Godspeed to you, Brown Hen; I hope you’re picking some worms up there or wherever dead chickens go.
So sorry for your loss of Brown/Red Hen. The hardest part of owning an Animal is saying goodbye.
The last gift we can give a pet or animal in our care is a good death. Thank you for sharing Brown/Red hens story.
Thanks Barbara…
Thank you for ending her suffering
To have any hen for 9 years is wonderful..mostly people only have them for a handful of years. I also have a 9 year old rooster and 7 year old hen..amazing they have lived that long and not got picked off by predators…you did the humane thing and whilst pet people. may or may not understand, farm animals are different. I never named my chickens either. I love them, but they are not my pets in the same way as my dogs.
My grandmother kept chickens but I could never understand how she could wring a hen’s neck, dip the carcass in boiling water, pluck the feathers, gut and cut it up, stew it with dumplings, and then serve and eat heartily with appetite.
That’s just what the farmers do, and they say the neck writing is the quickest and most humane way for chickens to die..
Just about a month ago, I had to make a decision about my 14 year old Golden. She had been doing great, but got sick, suddenly, on a Saturday afternoon/ evening in the middle of a snowstorm. My vet came to the house, gave her a shot, and said we would know by morning, if she was going to get better. I asked if this was it and she said she didn’t think so. However, by morning, it was apparent things were bad. She and a vet tech helped me get her to the clinic, which they opened for me. My vet said that she could give her fluids but I would be back in a few days. There was no way I was going to prolong her life for my selfish reasons. I held her and the.vet put her down. I am so thankful she didn’t suffer for days or weeks. We have to do what is best for our animals, not what is best for us. Ignore anyone who gives you grief about what you did for the red hen or any of your animals. You definitely did the right thing.
Ann, you had a lucky dog, thanks for the story.
Have provided for merciful deaths for a few animal companions…it’s how to love them “ all the way “
Wondering how White Hen is without her friend?
She can’t tell me, Alexa, but she is eating and behaving quite normally..chickens don’t mourn in my experience, they move on quickly. She looks quite content and is cleaning up on bugs and worms when we speak.
You and Maria are merciful, Jon.
Jon thank you sir for the merciful act.
I did this for my dog many years ago.
I struggled at first until someone said it was an act of Mercy. That helped in seeing it that way
Dawn Marie, thanks, that is the way I look at it. Ending an animal’s suffering is a true mercy.
I woke up last night and knew you would have to put her down before vacation. I hope it is not too hard on you, even though it is merciful. You have that hen a good long life and returned her to the nitrogen cycle where she will support other life.
Thank you for sharing this very personal experience. I greatly appreciate your clarity and balance on this matter. It is comforting to know I am not the only person who sees the life/death trajectory in this way.
I have made the same decision a few times in my experience raising chickens. I will be needing to make it again shortly. It is not easy, but it is necessary. Thank you.
How I wish that us humans could have a steward who could give us a dignified death. Maybe it’s coming – since there are a few states that allow it as long as qualifications are met. There is hospice as well. Animals cannot speak for themselves, so we have to interpret what they need – and like you said, you’ve had these animals for a long time and you know the signs of suffering.
This was well presented and well said. I know what you said about vets toughest time as mine wrote me a note thanking me for letting my little dog go, thus not allowing him to suffer, He had a stroke and I could not allow him to suffer that way. I once saw a couple carrying their dog out of a pet hospital to “take her home for a last weekend”, The dog was obviously suffering and I though the owners were selfish and uncaring; surely a lesson to us all.
Thanks Gene, that is what it means to be humane, I believe. Thanks for writing.