5 July

Knowing Robin. The Truth Will Always Set Me Free

by Jon Katz

I am often not able or willing to say the things people want me to say, but I am finally able to say or write the things I want to say that are true for me.

I’ve paid dearly for this; we are not a nation that values honesty or individuality.  The yentas are all over me.

Thoreau’s idea of independent integrity and thought is in peril. The poor man would have hung himself if Facebook was available at Walden Pond.

Somehow, we lost the spirit of our revolution and have evolved into a people demanding that we all say what others have decided we should say, and do what others tell us to do.

I knew from the start that I would never be one of those conventional Hallmark grandfathers whose lives evolved around their granddaughters and grandsons. Just wait, people said. This will be the best thing in your life.

But I wanted my life to be the best thing in my life. I didn’t know how to be like those other enthralled grandparents and it wasn’t me. To be truthful, it wasn’t what I really wanted.

I wanted to live my own life, not somebody else’s, which was hard enough. I wanted to be the eccentric granddad who challenged his granddaughter with new and different ideas. I had an uncle like that, he got me to be a writer.

But I have to say the pandemic made it impossible to really know my quite remarkable granddaughter as she was growing up. We haven’t seen one another for nearly three years, and re-connecting is proving challenging. Some people say Facetime works. But it doesn’t work for me.

If this was something Emma and I wanted to do, we might have figured out a way to do it. I have to be honest about that. But we have never been closer or easier with one another.

Emma gave me the great gift of her photography; I was able to follow Robin’s evolution from a toddler into an independent, articulate human being with loving parents who used New York City lovingly as a rich backdrop for raising their child.  Emma has been very faithful about that.

I saw Robin grow and blossom, just like my Begonias.

New York is a rough city, but a wonderful place to raise a child if you can afford it.

I didn’t get to see Robin growing up for myself; I got to see it on my Iphone and computer. That was better than not seeing it all, and I am grateful for it.

I’ve missed a critical period in Robin’s growth and am getting older. I’m not sure this narrative will change or how that might happen.

I believe strongly in the idea of radical acceptance. I accept a good and lucky life, and its ups and downs, and I celebrate what I do have, not what I don’t have.

I have a lot and give thanks for it every day.

Robin has a remarkable childhood; she is adored by her parents, exposed to every cultural offering of a great city, goes to one of the most respected schools in the country, and is confident, talented,  outgoing, and curious.

I don’t know if I could have offered her any gifts she doesn’t have; she does not strike me as needing much.

I send her books and toys all the time, and we talk on the phone once in a while. I am good at buying her the things she wants. That is something I can do, a connection of sorts.

It turned out the way I thought it would; she turned out better than I could have imagined. And she has a great mother and doting father.

Her other grandparents are more conventional and connected; she is lucky to have that.

She will do very well for herself, and if I wasn’t really to be a part of it – we don’t take vacations together, as she does every year with her other grandparents –  I can still enjoy it and take pleasure from it.

And I love those photographers Emma sends me, she is a brilliant photographer, that is a gift too.

5 Comments

  1. Check out Leslie Stahl’s book on grandparents.

    .it sounds like your attachment gene is turned off

    1. I’m good Tom, thanks for the idea but I’m not interested in other people’s grandparenting experiences. I don’t know what an attachment gene is (I can imagine), but if it’s turned off, then so be it…I’m very happy with my life. I am not Lesley Stahl…I notice Tom. that whenever I do something most other people don’t do or admit to feeling, people try to cure me, mostly by recommending things that have no relevance to me or my circumstances. Lesley Stahl and I lead very different lives, I would not presume to tell her how to be a grandparent. or assume that I might now. I presume she does what is best for her, as I do what is best for me.

      I hope there is no gene for killing individuality, and I don’t think I have attachment issues. I attach to lots of things. But since you don’t know me, you can’t know that. Best to you.

  2. I love your ho esty Jon. I have a zoom account and it is great for connecting with friends and family.

    1. Thanks, Nonna, I have one too. I’m not as comfortable with it as you are. I appreciate the good words.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email SignupFree Email Signup