10 May

Love Lives. A Wonderful Day At Bishop Maginn: We Brought The Prom Dresses, It Was One Of The Most Joyous And Meaningful Experiences Of My Life

by Jon Katz

The photos I took at Bishop Maginn today speak for themselves. I encourage you to look at them all. They are the faces of joy, friendship, love, and excitement.

As a man who has never been to a prom, I was slow to grasp the importance and meaning of the dresses Tania Woodward gathered to give to the Bishop Maginn High School students to wear to their last prom and Bishop Maginn’s last school activity.

I get it now—what a day of joy and laughter and community – and generosity. Bishop Maginn is one of the most diverse schools in the country, and I was struck again by how well the students mixed, and how much they cared for one another and root for each other.

It can be done. You can read Maria’s account of the day here.

(The first photo, above,  is of Say, whose tuition we helped pay last year. She has evolved into a strong, warm, and intelligent young person, loved by many friends and teachers. The photo took my breath away for a bit; it said it all.).

The prom night has enormous significance on many levels, but the distribution of the proms gave me – Maria also – one of the most joyous and meaningful days of our lives. We left with hour hearts up in the air.

We arrived with five huge sacks of prom dresses collected by friend Mansion aide Tania Woodard, whose family was too poor to buy her the dresses she dreamed of – much like the refugee children at BMHS.

                                               (Vonelise Washington)

Tania read about the prom on my blog and saw a chance to give other poor young women a chance to wear the kind of dresses she couldn’t afford as a child, and they couldn’t either – most are inner-city and refugee kids, and they are used to denial,  struggle and worse.

We showed up before noon, and it took six or seven strong boys and girls to get the bags into Sue Silverstein’s art room.

While I took pictures, Maria and Sue pulled the gowns out of their bags and hung them on Sue’s clothesline, and Maria helped put them up. The response was electric. The female students showed up in a stream that lasted all day, trying dresses on, rushing into the girl’s room to change, texting, laughing, blushing,  and e-mailing their mothers in excitement.

(Nashea Horne)

The room was mobbed from that point on. Principal Mike Tolan came in and told Sue, “well, I see nobody will be doing any work today.” Nobody did. Even the boys came in to see the excitement. I took many beautiful photos, and I want to share them with you.

“I can’t believe people gave us these beautiful dresses,” said one student, “thank you!”

(Nashua and Gabby Taylor)

 

The photos speak for themselves.

I am working on getting all the names right; they deserve no less. I am grateful to Sue, Maria, and Mike Tolan for letting this happen, especially to Tania Woodward, who spoke from the heart today.

She has added a sensational level of excitement and glamour to a prom already laden with meaning as these children leave the school that helped so many of them in their painful and often arduous journey to and into an angry and divided America.

For all of its troubles, this is where they want to be.

(Trinity Broderick)

This was a day that the good guys won; the others could spout all of the hatred and lies they want; this is what the human heart needs and wants to see.

I hope you can take the time to look at the pictures; all you need to see in the faces of these remarkable young people and what their prom – and their prom dresses – mean to them.

(Shanzay Malik)

“Where did this come from?” the kids and teachers asked me. “They came from somebody just like you,” I said, “a member of the Army Of Good who knows what it’s like to want a beautiful dress you can never have.” And yes, I saw, you do need to be female to grasp its power all.

(Asani Castillo found her dress)

All of us cried at one point or another today; it was one of the most incredible experiences. Come along and see.

Sue and Maria did a remarkable job of keeping everybody calm and displaying the dresses and helping the girls pick them out. One or the other held the gown up and one of the girls would raise their hands and come to try it on if interested.

Maria helped several shy girls change into their gowns, the girls were excited but well behaved. As news spread through the school about these beautiful gowns being given away, the room filled up and stayed full all afternoon.

(Say. Again.)

Principal Tolan was right. Nobody got any work done. By the end of school, all of the gowns were gone. The kids all asked where Zinnia was, but I had to tell them there was no room in the car for her; the back was stuffed to the ceiling with gowns.

(There was one set of tuxedo jackets and pants, and O’Zias Pollydore got it)

I was sorry Tania Woodward couldn’t be there to see the impact her gowns had on the school. She is exhausted, having worked long and grueling hours to fend off yet another Covid scare, along with the other Mansion aides. The Mansion is safe again, and I’m returning next week to resume my classes and visits with Zinnia.

(Camilla Rivera spotted this dress right away, and her friends raved about her appearance. She is quiet, even shy, but was delighted to find her prom dress. It did look great)

Sue Silverstein’s art room is a chaotic place in the best of times, kids show up at lunchtime to hang out, see friends, eat their fish n-chips and burgers at the tables, gossip and flirt, and I don’t think the room could have handled any more people today.

It is a fun place, a safe place, a loved place. Sue presides watchfully but lovingly. She has a great gift for getting children to behave without threats or stings.

(Emani Colon)

I asked each of the girls if they wanted to be photographed, and each one – even the shy ones – wanted to have their pictures taken. They were all beaming and proud, it was a joy to see them so excited, and the dresses made them even more excited about the problem, coming up in the middle of June, about a month away. It will be held at the school gym.

(Paris cheering on her friend Madison Chapple)

The care struck me the girls took with the dresses; they treated them gingerly and carefully. It seems that everyone who wanted a prom dress got one they liked. A few were working on making their own.

(Jazlyn Peralta)

One girl came in and scoffed at the very idea of a prom dress. “I’m not going to any prom,” she said. A half-hour later, I saw her take one across the hall to a classroom being used as a dressing area and came back quietly to ask Sue if she could take it and wear it to the prom. Sue said sure.

(Asani Once More

Thanks for looking at these pictures; they will lift the cold and most beleaguered heart. I hope you enjoy seeing them as much as I enjoyed taking them. This was a memorable day; I won’t soon forget it.

2 May

Four Books I’m Reading: The Rise Of Elon Musk, A Family Fights To Survive in Glasgow, Delicious Palace Intrigue, And The Truth About People We Love

by Jon Katz

The stack of books I’m reading or planning to read is growing. It changes almost every other day; I’m drowning in books I’m loving or sharing with you. I’m falling behind but will read every page.

This posting about my books has become a tradition I love, and from my messages, it’s appreciated.

I’m halfway through Rosie Walsh’s runaway mystery, The Love Of My Life, a book that will keep me on my toes and asks this question: do we know the people we love, marry and live with? I’m hooked.

This book is wonderfully well-plotted, and I’m not sure anyone in it, including a dog named John Keats, is really who they seem to be. I’m halfway through; I’m hooked and aren’t close to guessing it.

I’m going back and forth between Walsh’s book and the literary masterpiece Shuggie Bain by Douglas Stewart, a winner of England’s Booker Prize, perhaps the most prestigious award in all publishing. This is one of the best-written books I’ve ever read.

Shuggie Bain is a powerful, brilliantly written, and devastating book about a young gay man and his alcoholic mother fighting to survive and love each other in Glasgow during the 1980s.

The book is a remarkable chronicle of what it means to be gay, poor, and abandoned in one of the Western world’s poorest and most violent cities during a difficult time.

I’m halfway through, and I love every page, even though I take occasional brief breaks from it. The term can be overused, but this book is a masterpiece.

I got Tina Brown’s new book on the British Royal family’s painfully infamous troubles with women, from Camilla to Diana to Megan and Kate (and their husbands) and the woman who tried to control them,  Elizabeth – The Palace Papers: Inside the House of Windsor – the Truth and the Turmoil.

Some people might dismiss Brown’s thorough, revealing, and sensational story of these royal women as yet another gossipy exploitation of the Royal Family.  But Brown is a first-rate journalist, fact-driven, meticulous, thorough and knowledgeable.

This is much deeper than another tabloid tell-all.

It is a study of women in power and how difficult the world makes their lives. It is a story of love, ambition, loss, and human pain, all revolving around a thousand-year-old institution covered in dust and ritual and forever caught off guard and by surprise in modern times.

But I’m deep into it and like it a lot.

Brown, the former editor of the New Yorker Magazine, is a brilliant writer and a terrific reporter, the perfect formula for writing a much deeper book than it might seem to be, or then royal family books often are.

This is no gossip fest; it’s severe and well-researched and an essential book about our times and the deepening struggle of an ancient institution to survive in 2022.

Queen Elizabeth is likely to die soon, and there is a growing concern and speculation about whether the monarchy can survive her loss. Brown offers the most comprehensive study of what goes on inside those walls that I’ve yet to read.

There is plenty of riveting and fresh gossip that breaks through the protective wall that shrouds the most famous family in the world.

Still, this book is also a well-reported and credible story about women and the complexity and struggle of becoming famous. Every detail of their lives is raked over by the primarily male journalists dying to make them look bad and profit from it. Against them are a dusty, stuffy, cloistered Army of Palace Protectors of a Queen desperately trying to stop them, usually failing.

A thousand years ago, she could have banished all of them to some castle in Wales if they dared to challenge her. Now, she has to call strategy meetings with publicists.

As Brown points out, the Queen is the whole enterprise; to steal attention from her is heresy. Nothing is more important than here. Megan doesn’t see it that way; as Brown clarifies, nothing is more important than her.

And that is the core of the challenge facing the modern monarchy. If you can get Oprah to interview you and take your side, you are among the most influential people in the world.

Brown beats up almost everyone in the book except Camilla, Duchess of Cornwall; her husband Charles is the heir apparent to Queen Elizabeth, the next King of England, if his mother ever does die. In journalism, we understand that the people who are not skewered in revelatory books (think Bob Woodward) are invariably the ones who are telling tales.

Camilla, a possible future Queen, was unscathed. Nobody else in this saga was.

As portrayed in this serious, persuasive, and titillating book, the challenge for Queen Elizabeth is that her children and family and their partners – from Diana to Meghan to Charles to Andrew –  are as famous (or infamous) as she is, and much more interesting, if less respected.

While she keeps true to her determination to be the most reliable, dependable, and guarded public figure on the earth, her family can’t seem to go along with the program. She can’t chop off their heads any more; she has to watch almost helplessly as they get tangled in scandals or tell all to Oprah or defy and ignore her.

Times have changed; the Queen and her courtiers spend much of their time doing damage control on behalf of the young, the perverted, the foolish, and the ambitious. Who wants to live like that anymore if there’s a choice? You can’t control these people anymore!

Brown skewers Megan and Harry as self absurd and greedy brats who left the Royal Family and their duties for Netflix and a California mansion. They are seen as a betrayal. Megan perfected the role of the helpless victim of racism, and Harry is portrayed as emotionally unstable and self-pitying.

Megan, as Brown saw her was a brooding, power-crazed, volatile adolescent. And the racial context of her conflicts with the Palace was often too honest.

She could never understand the Palace, and the Palace – almost entirely white and subservient –  could never understand her. Neither side had any context for dealing with the other.

The monarchy is in trouble – the CEO of the enterprise, writes Brown, is nearly 100 years old, and her successor is well into his 70s.

No wonder they can’t figure out how to handle the young and the scheming and dissatisfied outsiders their children always seem to fall in love with.

These people still believe they are here because God put them here to rule over their people. Feminism, disloyalty, plotting and scheming, indiscretions and revelations, and media manipulation are centuries behind their coping abilities.

Diana left the family hating Charles and the rest of them, and she paid them back with a media payback campaign that went on for years. She knew she was more popular than any of them and used it as a weapon again and again. Charles, constantly stuffy and awkward (and in love with someone else since he was 21), was no match for his bitter ex-wife.

I can’t wait to keep reading this book.

Today, another book I’m dying to read arrived in the mail. This is Ashlee Vance’s much-praised biography of Elon Musk: Tesla, SpaceX, and the Quest For a Fantastic Future.

This is the best time to read this book as Musk has traumatized media and its pundits over his apparent purchase of Twitter. (My blog posts to Twitter, but there isn’t enough money to get me to post there.) My personal opinion is that the importance of Twitter is radically overblown.

Mostly, the tweeters talk to one another.

Journalists and media ideologues are desperate to label Musk; he is either the earth’s savior through his electric cards or a demon extremist eager to bring the pedophiles, liars, and conspiracy theorists back to Twitter.

But this is a person allergic to labels, and no label, political or otherwise, fits him.  He loves Twitter and is an almost obsessed Tweeter. True to the spirit of Twitter, he is often cruel and cutting in his tweets. Why not? So is everyone else?

He is an original thinker; he thinks for himself and is not afraid to Tweet wildly and irresponsibly about it, just like Mr. Trump.

Musk had done more to fight climate change than anyone else in the world and, at the same time, rushes to defend Donald Trump when he was kicked off of Twitter for being a chronic liar and treasonous hypocrite.

Musk is a hero to millions of young people worldwide and has 80 million followers on Twitter. He is a hero to more people than any other public figure in America, including Donald Trump.

Musk’s posts make Donald Trump look like the corrupt and hopeless old fart that he is. I wonder if my former colleagues in the media will ever figure out that Trump is over, as stale as a five-day-old fish. Musk, for all his faults, is very much alive.

I haven’t read the book yet, but Musk is the most fascinating of the small but growing Army of Billionaires eager to own our media, our culture, and perhaps our politics.

Yes, the billionaires are taking over the public institutions and ideas that bind us or once did, from Fox News to The Washington Post to outer space to the Atlantic to the Los Angeles Times, and now to Twitter (did I forget to mention Mark Zuckerberg?

Musk is the most exciting visionary of the bunch. I do not doubt that he will defy any label people might want to put on him and bless him.

His life is all about doing things everyone else believed impossible to do.

He’s made electric cars the most popular cars globally, steamrolling and humiliating giants like GM and Ford. He might save the planet.

He’s revived space and space travel all by himself (Jeff Bezos is out there too). Now he says he has an idea for re-imaging and radically improving Twitter, now one of the most central and influential information entities in the world.

If successful, he could transform the very idea of modern media. I doubt he will turn the site over to the far right or the far light. Nothing would make him happier (or me, for that matter) than for the extremes at either end of the spectrum to hate him equally.

Musk is not only playing with the big boys now; he is just about to be the biggest boy of them all.

I don’t know what to make of him,  except that his accomplishments are staggering, and I am eager to read Ashlee Vance’s reportedly excellent account of who he is, where he comes from, and how he has accomplished what he has accomplished.

I see Musk as a genius, a true visionary,  an idiot savant, and an insecure adolescent who, like Steve Jobs, sees well into the future, is ruthless and unforgiving to stupidity, failure, and incompetence. Of course, he is dangerous. But he is also capable of great things, as he has already proven.

He is way too smart to be a tool of one side. What would the point of that be for such an independent thinker and sometimes mystic? He does seem to see the future. He might end up owning it.

Musk doesn’t think that small, for better or worse. Labels are about people who don’t wish to think. Musk is all about thinking.

So this book is very welcome to me; I can’t wait to read it. This is someone I want to understand. I hope to get a sense of him.

So I’ve got some great reading to do—a stack of riches.

Now, all I have to do is make time for it.

27 April

The Art Of Listening. When Understanding And Love Are Inseparable

by Jon Katz
Understanding And Love

The Art Of Listening by the famed psychoanalyst Erich Fromm was published in 1994, it became an instant classic and new and hardcover copies sell for up to $1,900. I have been looking for this book for a while, and finally came across a bookseller in England who had a paperback in good shape that he sold me for $50. I found out later that is in prison there and runs a used book business out of his cell in Cellblock J, his return address.

The book arrived today, and I am hooked on it, I’ve already turned down a dozen pages and will be up late reading it. I understand why it is so popular and difficult to find.

My prisoner-bookseller has a 99 percent approval rating on Amazon, and I was happy to give him five stars. Maybe I can get him up to 100.

I was despairing of ever being able to afford this book and I did not wish to read it on a Kindle. My copy is already thumbed and worn.

Fromm’s book is really about the power of analysis, but for many, it was his writing about listening and the search for unselfish understanding that drew me. I believe our culture and it’s people are forgetting how to listen, I know a handful of people in my life who understand that listening is an art, and is also the key to love.

Unselfish understanding is truly selfless, it is not about what we think or feel, it is about what someone else feels and understands. And if you can’t care about others, you cannot possibly understand them.

A woman messaged me this morning, she was unhappy that I was helping undocumented agricultural workers – some people still call them illegal aliens –  because it is harsher. She could not understand why I helping our friend Camilla, she entered the country illegally and thus, she said forfeited any kind of sympathy or constitutional rights.

I was struck not by the fact that this woman disagreed with what I was doing, which is perfectly acceptable to me, but with her inability to have any kind of empathy for this women who gets up at 5 a.m. every cold winter morning and every other day of the year to clean up pig slop in knee-deep mud and manure and is thus partly responsible for the fact that we have food to eat.  Her life is bounded by a small and decrepit trailer and the farm where she works and the houses that she cleans.

There is, I imagine, and any farmer will testify, not an American in our whole country who will apply for this work or do it.

I understand that we cannot let the whole troubled earth enter our country illegally and without resources and  hope to survive, but I can still feel empathy for the people who have come for no other reason than to feed themselves and their families, or to escape slaughter and genocide. That, to me, can never be a crime, even if they cannot remain here. To me, empathy is not about agreement but about listening and understanding.

Our political system, to which we are now paying a frightening amount of  addictive attention, is devoid of listening or understanding, and is thus ill. So are the many people whose hearts have turned to stone and who blindly follow equally addictive ideologies and arguments and  become damaged and corrupted by them.

As someone who underwent analysis in New York City in its final sunset years in the 1980’s, I find the book especially powerful.  I am so grateful for my time in analysis. Every good thought I have ever had comes from there.

Analysis is all about listening, so is life. And so is love and empathy.

The experience of analysis, something no insurance will pay for now, transformed me and was the beginning of my long and hard path to self-awareness and authenticity. I am still on that path, and will one day die on it.

“Understanding and love are inseparable, “writes Fromm, “If they are separate, it is a cerebral process and the door to essential understanding remains closed.” That quote seems to capture the disease sweeping out country and its civic life.

Psychoanalysis, writes Fromm, is a process of understanding a person’s mind, particularly that part which is not conscious. It is an art like the understanding of poetry. The basic rule for practicing the art of self-awareness and consciousness is the art of listening, he writes. The analyst listens to the analysand, and the analysand learns to listen to himself or herself.

Fromm offers six rules and norms for the art of listening:

1. The basic rule for practicing this art is the complete concentration of the listener.

2. Nothing of importance must be on his or her mind, he must be optimally free from anxiety as well as from greed.

3.He must possess a freely working imagination which is sufficiently concrete to be expressed in words.

4. She or he must be endowed with a capacity for empathy with another person and strong enough to feel the experience of the other as if it were his own.

5. The condition for such empathy is a crucial facet of the capacity for love.

To understand another means to love him or her – not in the erotic sense, but in the sense of reaching out to him or her and of overcoming the fear of losing oneself. It is a profound spiritual experience for me to truly understand someone who makes me uncomfortable or whom i strongly disagree with.

6. Thus understanding and love are inseparable. One without the other is an intellectual, not an emotional experience and the door to true understanding is slammed shut.

I appreciate the wisdom of these rule and norms. They are difficult to achieve, and few people try or even seem to grasp what listening is at this moment in time. We are at a point in our world where we are forever shouting at one another, talking right over each other’s heads, and the more we talk and argue the less we understand.

Many people listen only for the chance to reply.

Like the analyst, the listener must not try to please or impress, but rest within him or herself. And that is the hard part, to understand someone else we must first try to understand ourselves. In my relationship with Maria, I always understood that love was not possible without understanding.

The more we understood one another, the more we loved one another, in some strange way, it was just that simple.

Love and understanding are truly inseparable, and true understanding is impossible with empathy, the ability to understand others and to care for them, no matter what they say or believe.

Listening is an art, and one of the gifts of the past few months is that I am inspired to listen, not to shout.

Some years ago, I gave up asking “what happened to me?,” and instead began to ask “how do I feel?”

I am finally getting somewhere.

21 April

When My Heart Is Wide And Open

by Jon Katz
When Your Heart Is Wide And Open

Susan M is one of a number – a hundred perhaps, maybe more, I call them The Faithful – people who have been reading me a long time, first through my books, and then through the blog. These people have a kind of hallowed status for me, they have been patiently following my life for more than a decade, sometimes longer, and they write me every now and then to remark on my evolution – or failure – to evolve as a human being.

They see my successes and failures, strengths and weaknesses, and are not afraid to comment on any of those things. We are like a close and trusting family, we will never turn our backs on one another, and they have seen it all, poor things. I think there is nothing they could see that would cause me to turn a way, nothing I can do or write that would turn them away from me.

I respect them and listen to them, they have never abandoned me and I will never abandon them. And even thought they are  bounded and thoughtful, I graciously accept their advice and observations and even their intrusions. They have earned them.

Sometimes I can answer them, sometimes not, but they want nothing from me other than to be honest and happy and successful. Even I can’t quarrel with that.

I am deeply, and truly touched that these people – their messages are always thoughtful and compassionate – have stayed with me for so long. Today Susan wrote me to thank me for writing about my granddaughter Robin’s impending visit, about our undocumented friend Camilla’s search for refuge.

“I applaud you and Maria for trying to provide solace and help for Camilla – thank you for yet another thought-provoking and heartfelt post. Your heart is wide open…”  Susan.

I think Susan is right. My heart is wide open these days. I credit Maria for opening it some years ago, the heart surgeons for opening it up quite literally several years ago, and lately, Mr. Trump for opening it wider. I bear no hatred or contempt for the man, I hope he is a successful President for the sake of the country, and that he one day tries to unite us,  but  in the meantime he has challenged me to decide just who I am and who I wish to be.

More than anything, I wish to be a man with a merciful and open heart in a time when so many hearts have turned to stone. Robin has, of course has opened my heart further, but I have no wish to be over the wall or over the top in my love for her, despite the many messages I get telling me that has happened.

It is good just where it is, it really doesn’t need to go a lot farther. That has been a good lesson for me in life. Sometimes where you are is precisely where you need to be.

The residents of the Mansion and the refugees and the millions of mostly hard-working  illegal immigrants have touched my heart deepest of all, except for Maria. After all, Robin does not need me as much as Camilla does, she is loved, well cared for and content. The Mansion residents are appreciating some help, and that is the thing about help: it helps.

They have opened my heart and they keep it open. Their love and trust is soul food for me.

One woman wrote me yesterday, she hadn’t read the blog for a while, and she told me I had changed, and become a different person. I thanked her for that, but I also told her that I don’t believe anyone can ever become a different person. We are not light bulbs that can be unscrewed and replaced.

At times I am better, at times I am worse, I am a work in progress, I hope I will never see myself as being done.

Our souls and spirits are not transferable, they cannot be wiped clean and discarded. I am not a different person, that is not possible, I am the very same person trying to learn and grow, and where possible, change. I don’t trust anyone who claims to be a different person, I think all of us can be a better person than we are. That is the miracle of being human, no dog or horse or elephant or squirrel can set out to do that.

Living with Maria, I think my heart will never close again.

I thank you Susan, for your thoughts about my heart, it was good to hear from you again, and I hope you are well. I am grateful for you. I think of my heart as being like a proud and vintage car. A lot of work has been done it, and sometimes, on the road, it runs wide and open.

It’s a good feeling for sure, free and uplifting and full of promise.

 

Bedlam Farm